Always homemade

Flavors for every craving

Pick a classic, try a Hilltop favorite, or mix a few flavors in a sampler. Vegan and no sugar added options are available too.

Scoops of strawberry, vanilla, and chocolate ice cream arranged side by side

Made in house

Homemade Flavors

Ask us which flavors are being scooped today.

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Strawberry

  • Bear Tracks

    Double chocolate ice cream, peanut butter wafers, cashews, and chocolate chips

  • Butter Pecan

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Cookie Dough

    Homemade chocolate chip cookie dough

  • Lemon Cream

  • Lavender honey ice cream in waffle cones with honeycomb and lavender Orange ice cream cones arranged on a pink surface

  • Coffee Heath Bar

  • Coffee Oreo

  • Birthday Cake

  • Cotton Candy

  • Orange Creamsicle

  • Lavender Honey

  • Andes Mint Chip

  • Mint Oreo

  • Assorted ice cream scoops with cherries, whipped cream, sprinkles, and chocolate chips Colorful ice cream cups topped with whipped cream and sprinkles

  • Cherry Goat Cheese

    Fresh goat cheese ice cream with dark cherry jam

  • Salted Caramel

  • Coconut Joy

    Toasted coconut ice cream with dark chocolate covered almonds

  • Chocolate Brownie

  • Peanut Butter Cup

    Peanut butter ice cream with homemade peanut butter cups

  • Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake

    Made with Imladris Farm blueberry jam

  • Sour Patch Kids Sorbet

    Sour lime and watermelon

Something for everyone

No Sugar Added

Sweetened with xylitol and agave nectar

  • Mocha Almond
  • Lemon Cream

Vegan

Dairy free options

  • Raspberry Basil Sorbet
  • Salted Caramel Cookie Oatmilk Ice Cream

Build your treat

Scoops & Cones

1 Scoop

$4.75

Choose 1 or 2 flavors

2 Scoops

$5.75

Choose 1 or 2 flavors

Sampler

$6.75

Choose 3 or 4 flavors

Homemade Waffle Cone

Add $1.25

Cake Cone

Sugar Cone

A hand holding a cup of ice cream outside Hilltop Ice Cream Shop A cup of strawberry ice cream with a spoon

Menu items and availability may change.